Supreme Court record · 24-1287 and 25-250
Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump
SourcesSupreme CourtLearning Resources v. TrumpSupreme CourtDocket 24-1287APTariff authority
Legal question
Does the International Emergency Economic Powers Act authorize the challenged tariffs?
Holding
The Court held that IEEPA did not authorize the challenged tariffs.
Practical effect
The decision makes the boundary between Congress's statutory delegation and presidential implementation concrete: courts interpret whether the executive stayed within the authority Congress supplied.
The court’s voices
Opinions
Opinion announcing the judgment
Chief Justice John Roberts
Joined by: Justice Sonia Sotomayor, Justice Elena Kagan, Justice Neil Gorsuch, Justice Amy Coney Barrett, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson
Six justices joined the portions concluding that IEEPA did not authorize the challenged tariffs; the opinion was fragmented on parts of its reasoning.
SourcesSupreme CourtLearning Resources v. TrumpSupreme CourtDocket 24-1287
Concurrence
Justice Neil Gorsuch
Gorsuch wrote separately while joining the controlling portions identified in the judgment.
Concurrence
Justice Amy Coney Barrett
Barrett wrote separately while joining the controlling portions identified in the judgment.
Concurrence in part and in the judgment
Justice Elena Kagan
Joined by: Justice Sonia Sotomayor, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson
Kagan agreed with the judgment and portions of the Court's reasoning.
Concurrence in part and in the judgment
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson
Jackson agreed with the judgment and wrote separately about interpretive method.
Dissent
Justice Clarence Thomas
Thomas would have upheld broader presidential authority under the statute.
Dissent
Justice Brett Kavanaugh
Joined by: Justice Clarence Thomas, Justice Samuel Alito
Kavanaugh disagreed with the Court's statutory analysis and judgment.
Opinions and materials
- OpinionSlip opinion (opens in a new tab)
Supreme Court of the United States
- DocketSupreme Court docket and judgment (opens in a new tab)
Supreme Court of the United States